Tuesday, October 16, 2018


1.      Introduction

 

One of the most critical functions in an organization is Human Resource Management. Subsequently the only live resource in an organization is human being, it is very difficult to dealing with people.  A key determinant of performance and stability of an organization is the internal customers. Human resource has many features that the other resources do not possess. Key function of any scale organization all over the world is the managing human resources.

Recruitment and selection process  

‘The process of attracting individuals on a timely basis, in sufficient numbers and with appropriate qualifications, to apply for jobs with an organization’ (Gusdorf, 2008, P.171)

 If HR planning indicates the need for addition labor, there are number of choices to make. The first step would be recruitment and selection process and sometimes hiring additional employees is not the good t method to obtain additional labor. Organization can consider alternatives to recruiting, such as outsourcing or contingent labor, instead of hiring regular employees (Dessler 2011) Part-time labor or overtime by existing employees would be solutions for a temporary fluctuation in work volume and it would be the simple solution. Hiring new employees should happen only after careful consideration and only when the organization anticipates a long-term need for additional labor (John ,2009)

Estimates on the cost to replace supervisory, technical and management employees run from 50 percent to several hundred percent of employee salaries. To accurate forecasting of future labor needs, carefully HR planning must consider the overall growth prospects of the organization. Promotion from within your organization’s promotion policy will have a significant effect on the recruitment process.

The most common method used to find qualified applicants from inside the organization is job posting (John ,2009) JOB POSTING: The procedure to inform employees that job openings exist.It may be appropriate to promote someone already working for the organization, if the open position is above entry level. A reward for good work or longevity with the organization, organization use promotion as a motivation tool (Amstrong,2010). Employees become more aware of their own career opportunities, when they see their co-workers being promoted. Promotion is very important in current environment where employee have little chance of improving their lot by changing organizations.by having improvement within their current organization, employee have opportunity for career growth and increased income. When organization promote the exsistine employee, employee will be comfortable with the corporate culture, knows organization policies and will likely get up to speed much faster than a person new to the organization(Kaur ,2013)

 “The problem with promotion from within is that the promoted person leaves a staffing gap in his or her so there is still a position to be filled  and  “That gap is likely to be at a lower, less-skilled position, and therefore it may be an easier position to fill” (Gusdorf, 2008, p 171)

Advantages of internal recruitment

The advantages of internal recruitment and selection are as follows (Daft ,2009)

  • ·         It's quicker
  • ·         It's easier
  • ·         It’s less risky
  • ·         It’s improve employee brand
  • ·         It’s boost employee engagement


Disadvantages of internal recruitment and selection

The Disadvantages of internal recruitment and selection are as follows (Daft ,2009)

  • Cons it could cause internal conflict
  • They may not be respected by others
  • External recruitment is the evaluation of open of job candidates, other than existing staff, to check whether there are any enough talented or able to fill requirement and perform existing employment opportunities (Dessler ,2011)

Advantages of External recruitment and selection

The advantages of external recruitment and selection are as follows (Daft R L ,2009)

  • ·         Increased chances
  • ·         Fresher skill and input
  • ·         Qualified candidates
  • ·         Better competition
  • ·         Lesser internal politics


  • Advantages of External recruitment and selection

The Disadvantages of external recruitment and selection are as follows (Daft ,2009)

  • ·         A limited understanding about the company
  • ·         Higher risk
  • ·         Time consuming
  • ·         High costs
  • ·         Internal disputes with existing employees


The strength of the economy and labor market conditions will significantly affect the organization’s ability to attract and retain top-level employees. Organization has to compete with other employers for a limited number of skilled employees, as the economy is strong and with little unemployment (Khanna,2014). To attract quality applicants organization require increased compensation or benefits incentives (Khanna,2014).

The best way to avoid the trauma and expense of a lawsuit is to simply not discriminate (Kayode,2013) Focus   recruitment and hiring decisions on job skills and qualifications, endeavoring to find the best person for the job (Kayode, 2013)


 Background of the organization

The Bank which I work for is a leading commercial Bank in Sri Lanka since 1999 Bank has emerged as a top of the range Human Resource solutions provider to customers around the globe servicing companies of all sizes and diverse industries. The Bank has over 100 branches all over island wide.

Providing on-premise and cloud-based HRIS as well as Outsourcing services  into both HR and IT, Bank enables companies to work more effectively and to achieve better results in terms of both Human Resource Management and overall performance of the organization. The success at Bank lies with a dedicated team of professionals geared towards one common goal of providing quality Human Resource solutions.
The Bank is providing a comprehensive, effective and efficient way to manage and develop Employees; the most valuable asset in an organization. This Bank provides a comprehensive set of functionalities to address Human Resource Management needs of any organization. Bank is a perfect platform for aligning your HR processes and achieving higher standards of human capital management as a web based application with features reflecting the latest developments in HR Management

Recruitment and selection

Recruitment and selection process in a series of  hurdles aimed at selecting the best candidate for the job ( Muhammad,  Hamad, Batool,2014) Recruitment and selection refers to the chain and sequence of activities pertaining to recruitment and selection of employable candidates and job seekers for an organization. Every organization has some well-defined employment and recruitment policies and hiring procedures( Muhammad, Hamad, Batool,2014).The HR department of large organizations, businesses, government offices and multilateral organizations are generally vested with the responsibilities of employee recruitment and selection (Piatkowski,2014).

Process of recruitment and selection





 (Source: Dessler and Varkkey, year 2011)

 In a process of recruitment and selection in first have to forecast on employment planning  and is build a pool of candidates.HR team will collect complete application forms from applicants and have to use selection tools like tests to screen out applicants. Finally throughout the supervision and interviews final candidates to be chosen final candidates

Employee selection is an important activity of HRM, and the benefits of effective recruitment and selection given below (Daft, 2009)

1.   Business goals and objectives are better achieved by selecting employees whom you feel will add value to your company.
2.      An incompetent employee is a liability to your business, they're also an additional expense and a burden that you don't need.
3.      Personnel requirements vary from job to job.
4.      People have varying degrees of intelligence, aptitudes and abilities.
5.      Labor Laws protect employees, thus making it difficult to fire incompetents and problem cases
6.      Individuals have different interests, goals, and objectives in life.

3.2.1        Selection of Graduate/ Management trainees of Bank
The number of step has been experienced by Bank to select graduate/ management trainees as it is very important to fulfill best person to junior software development. Bellow steps have taken to select best candidate from the pool.

·         Screening and short listing of application
  • Preliminary interviews
  • Tests (Technical Test/ Practical Test)
  • Secondary interviews with HR and Final Interviews with the Director/ General Manager
  • Selection decision
3.2.1.1        Screening and short listing of application

It is already decided to recruit graduate/ management trainees by properly analyzing job condition of Bank. Selection process is functioning under close review of HR department.

The CVs received from the universities and internal employees are screening and short listing under several criteria such as the specialization of the degree, period of training, projects experience.

Bank has recruited five to six Graduate/ Management trainees per year for six months training and 12 months training. After the training period the Trainees are evaluate by the department heads and direct supervisors and recruit selected trainees to permanent carder as Associate Software Engineer.

Table 3.1 explains the criteria and requirements which Bank take in to consideration to select best candidates from the pool.

3. 1 Table: Short Listing criteria, requirements and remarks


Criteria
Requirement
Looked at
Remarks
Qualifications
Degree
Degree with a Class or General Degree
Point scheme set to evaluate degree criteria, specialization etc.
Membership of a recognized Professional Body
Membership
Partial qualification
Points for membership, partial qualifications for relevant professional qualifications.
Experience
Industrial Experience
Project Experience and technical experience
Depending on the projects and Time worked applications will be sorted in to Management trainee and Graduate trainee criteria.

Criteria
Requirement
Looked at
Remarks
Personality
Permanent disability
Other moral qualities
Disability will not cause rejection.

Human skills
Special attention should be given to disabled candidates at the selection test (reserving special slots of time and venues)
Extracurricular activities may show the human skills of candidates.


3.2.1.2 Preliminary interview
After screened out the applications the organization will call interview for selected applicants who enable to pass through screen unit. The Bank is conducting the structured interview to select the person.

Within the interview, the Bank mainly worried about the attitude, value, believes of the person rather than experience as graduate/ management trainee position is concerned. The Bank trusts the status of person and his knowledge and skills are directly affected to the performance of the organization.
1        Appearance
2        Drive & Initiative
3        Friendliness
4        Attitudes
5        Personality
6        Learning curve
7        Confidence
8        Experience
9        Conversational ability
10    Qualification
11    Attention to details
12    Computer Skills

The purpose of preliminary interviewing is to appoint the best person for the job based solely on merit and suitability. The Bank selection framework reaches this by using methods that are systematic, thorough, fair, unbiased and based on rational, objective, job related criteria.

The preliminary interview is doing by a technical person who is attached to software development such as Senior Manager. The interviewer is evaluating the candidate by considering following criteria.
At the interview, each candidate should be treated consistently. To achieve this panel should;
  • ·     Ask the same initial questions of each candidate – self introduction
  • ·  Supplement their understanding of the candidate’s responses by following up questions as appropriate.
  • ·  Be consistent in allowing access to presentation material, notes and so on if necessary or request by interviewers.
  • ·  Not allow any unfair questions, harassment, or any other conduct which breaches the Bank equal opportunities policy or code of conduct.
  • ·   Secure that information gained throughout the selection process is treated as confidential and is known only to parties involved in the selection process.
  • ·   Keep records of interviews and the reasons for decisions - returning this information to HR for filing. 
  • · Panel members would be alert that it is their responsibility to ensure recruitment/interview documentation is stored securely and confidentially whilst in their possession.


33.2.1.3.  Selection tests



The Bank is conducting two selection tests for their candidates. Normally Bank used to give written exam and IQ test as a selection tool for Graduate/ Management trainees. If the candidate is got through the written exam he/ she have to do practical test. Examination consists of mainly two parts;

  1. IQ - Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs) – 1hour
  2. General knowledge  – 1hour

IQ test and General knowledge  are marked by HR. Marks are released within 1 to 2 days and the candidates who got highest marks for two tests will be call for practical test (2 hours). Based on the written tests the HR and the Head of development will finalized the candidates for secondary interview.

Bank held responsibility about the validity and reliability of the tests and the confidentiality of marks.

3.2.1.4  Secondary and Final interviews

This in-depth interview will focus on niche and soft skills. The “Soft skills” of a candidate are gauged by with interview techniques. Technical skills are scrutinized by utilizing customized screening methods that will be identified throughout the initial meeting.

The HR department mostly HR manager or Senior HR Executive will do the secondary interview to evaluate the reality of the candidate profile in terms of human related skills and attitudes stated in the Curriculum vitae. Here looked at the culture of candidates at the level of organizational culture.

The selected candidates from the secondary interview will be call for final interview with the Director/ General Manager. The main purpose of the interview is to finalize the candidates for the vacant position.

3.2.1.5 Selection Decision

After implementation the all above filtering processes, Bank has to acquire approval from CEO and uncertainty he approved, the HR department will send the employee’s details to finance department in order to make the appointment letter and the contract for training. Once received the appointment letter and the contract from the finance, the HR department will call the candidates to signing the agreement. Here HR department will clarify all the terms and conditions of the agreements and ask them to sign each and every page of the agreement.

Conclusion and Recommendations

One of the most important functions of the HR department is Recruitment and selection. , selecting and recruiting should be accurate and qualified as the talents should come in to the Organization.
Organization should be focused on:
  1. §  Recognize  basics of recruitment & selection process
  2. §  Current trends in recruitment
  3. §  Motivational issues that interests excellence employees.






References

Armstrong, M & Taylor, S (2014), Armstrong’s Handbook of Human Resource Management Practice, Thirteenth edition, London, United Kingdom

Armstrong, M (2014), Armstrong’s Strategic Human Resource Management A Guide to Action, Fourth edition, London, United Kingdom

Armstrong, M.(2010) Armstrong's Essential :Human Resource Managewment Practice, Guide to People Management. London : Kogan Page Limited .

Benson S G and Dundis S P (2003) Understanding and motivating health care employees: integrating Maslow's hierarchy of needs, training and technology, Journal of Nursing Management, Vol 11, pp. 315–320

Chungyalpa W and Karishma T (2016), Best Practices and Emerging Trends in Recruitment and Selection, Journal of Entrepreneurship & Organization Management 2016

Daft, R., L., (2009) Principles of Management, New Delhi: Cengage Learning India (Pvt) Limited

Dessler, G.(2011). Human Resource Management, (12th Ed.). New Delhi: Prentice Hall of India Private Limited.

Isenhour, L C, Lukaszewski K M, Stone, D L (2014), Organizational attraction factors: A technology perspective, Journal of Technology Research, Vol 5 

Kaur, A (2013) Maslow’s Need Hierarchy Theory : Applications and Criticisms, Global Journal of Management and Business Studies, Vol 3, No. 10, pp. 1061-1064

Kayode, O (2013) Application of Theory X & Y in Classroom Management, International Journal of Education and Research, Vol 1, No. 5

Khanna, P (2014) Recruitment & Selection - A need of the hour for organizational success, International Journal of Research in Management & Technology,Vol. 4, No.3, June 2014

Mohamed, R K M H & Nor, C S M, (2013), The Relationship between McGregor's X-Y Theory Management Style and Fulfillment of Psychological Contract: A Literature Review International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, May 2013, Vol. 3, No. 5

Muhammad, A, Hamad, N, Batool, A, (2014) Impact of Recruitment and selection of HR Department Practices, European Journal of Business and Management, Vol 6, pp No 31
Piatkowski, M (2004), People Selection Process for Implementing Lean Manufacturing, F.S.P. Consulting Inc.
 
Ployhart, R E (2006) Staffing in the 21st Century : New Challenges and Strategic Opportunities, Journal of Management


Robert, L., H., John, H., J., (2009) Human Resource Management,(13th Ed.). USA: South Western Cengage Learning

























16 comments:

  1. Versatile topic that helps the readers to have a better idea of what is really happening at the HR department that most of the employees don’t have access to. People merely think that recruitment & selection is a simple process & disregarded its importance most of the time. The blog has given a precise view of the process. Simply Anosh et al (2014) presented that recruitment is defined as process of generating a pool of capable people to apply for an employment in an organization, and selection is act of selecting one or more people from that group or set of people (Anosh et al, 2014).

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good read Dilshani, the best recruitment and selection strategies play an important role in Human Resource Management. Furthermore (Kumari, 2012) says that according to David A De Cenzo, there are three (3) types of recruitment needs, they are ;

    (a) Planned Needs – Needs which arise from changes in the company and retirement policy creating vacancy for new jobs.

    (b) Anticipated Needs – Movements in personal which a company can predict by studying trends both external and internal environment.

    (c) Unexpected Needs – These type of needs arise due various reasons such as deaths, resignation, accidents, illness, relocation.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dilshani, Good work on topic. Organization should strictly focus on the quality of methods used when selecting the right people at right time .Considering the prevailing situation of high turnover of employees in banking industry, the organization should apply well-built & effectual techniques to enhance the engagement for the sustainability. Selecting the right applicant can be a difficult task, but at the end of the day, the organization’s reputation is held by the people it employs (Henry & Temtime, 2009).

    ReplyDelete
  4. It’s an interesting article Dilshani, anyhow the private organizations is going through a trend of Nepotism which may give mixed benefits to the company.
    Many organizations have nepotism policies and it’s important to find out where your employer stands on the issue of nepotism. When hiring relatives, most employers require family members to work in different areas of the organization to prevent issues of favoritism and possible morale problems among employees. It is never appropriate for family members to be in supervisory positions where they are required to manage their own relatives.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The blog clearly emphasizes on the topic of Recruitment and selection process which is one of the vital components of a strategic human resource management process of an organization. As per Armstrong and Taylor, (2014, p.226) Recruitment is the process of finding and engaging the people the organization needs. Selection is that part of the recruitment process concerned with deciding which applicants or candidates should be appointed to jobs. And the blog has comprehensively spoken about its topic.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dilshani,good to read and well constructed Blog on Recruitment and selection process.Very interesting flow on the features and the content of the information gathered.
    I wish to further add that for the recruitment & selection process to be effective, it is essential to recognize the organizational values as well as the culture and the candidates’ profiles are assimilated with them, ultimately only the ones who ‘Best Fit’ are engrossed to the organization (Armstrong, 2008). The best-fit approach emphasizes that HR strategies should be depending on the context, circumstances of the organization and its type as well (Armstrong, 2008).

    Well done Dishani for the tremendous effort delivered on the assignment.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Recruitment and selection also has an important role in ensuring worker performance and positive organizational out come.it is often claimed that selection of workers occurs not just to replace departing employees or to add to a workforce but rather aims to put in place workers who can perform at a high level and demonstrate commitment.(Ballantyne,2009)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Recruitment is such a critical factor for an organization since it is the process which the organization selects the team or the individuals who are capable of carrying out the organizational objectives. According to Gamage (2014) the objectives of selection function are to get the right person to the right job; unless inefficient staff will be filled in the organization. The selected staff needs to be capable of doing the selected job. This is the most important factor in a proper recruitment and selection process.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Dilshani
    Hi Dilshani, the blog you have discussed about clearly explains ways and means of effective recruitment and selection process. This comment would be further strengthen the subject. As main sources of recruitment are;

    Advertisement- Certain important aspects are consider the location of the advertisement, its title, placement of the logo and graphics with a right language. (Arthur, 2005).
    Campus Recruitment- Organizations find inexperienced candidates from various fields of study from educational institutions like colleges and universities (Rao, 2009).
    Recruiting Firms- Employment agencies, which are generally used for junior level, clerical, semi-skilled positions; and Executive search firms, which are focusing on professional careers (Arthur, 2005).
    Job Portals/Organizational Websites-
    Job Fairs/Exhibitions- Important in establishing new contacts with other organizations which contributes to cooperation and exchange of information. (Arthur, 2005).
    Headhunting- Advantages of headhunting are reducing advertising and administrative costs, confidence in the skills and qualifications of the candidate, ability to attract the most talented employees (Patel & Rana, 2007).
    Other Sources-

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi Dilshani, it is an interesting reading regarding the recruitment and selection process with practical application and you have very well linked your working experience in the banking industry as well. In the present business context, recruitment and selection can be considered as one of the major features of strategic human resource management which is known as SHRM, since it is the people or employees who can ensure that the organizational objectives are targeted and achieved (Argue 2015).

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hi Dilshani, According to (leonard 2017) As a business owner, you want a team that you can count on to get the job done while you focus on other things. Management of any large corporation will tell you that finding good, loyal talent is hard. Take the time to develop a recruiting process that is constantly looking for people with the skills you need and the motivation to work for you. A good process not only finds great employees but saves you time and money on replacing and training new people.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi Dilshani, Interesting Blog and organisation must pay their attention on budget limitation at the recruitment strategy formulation stage further following areas also need to be consider. at the strategy formulation stage. (Breaugh et al. 2008, 48.)
    Who should be recruited?
    - Where to recruit?
    - When to recruit?
    - What recruitment sources should be used?
    - What message should be communicated?
    - Who should carry out the recruitment process?

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hi Dilshani! You have comprehensively discussed the topic of recruitment and selection which is key to any organization who intends to thrive even under the most trying conditions where with the right workforce in the organization will ensure not merely the survival but the progression of the organization. However, the integrity of those who are in authority to select and recruit the correct personnel without being bias is an essentiality that should be a foregone conclusion. It is of primary importance that cannot be contravened at any cost where in carrying out the task of recruitment and selection procedure for impartiality and fair play to be strictly observed (Klug, 2017).

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi Dilshani, you have clearly explained about the recruitment and selection process and it is very interesting to read. In your blog, it is very vibrant that the internal source of recruitment can be measured as the basic procedure of the HR needed by the managers and the Employees. Internal recruitment helps in growth of the human resource by offering several chances of the career to the employees inside the Company and for managers deliver oriented and trained employees for the vacancies.
    Other way of the internal recruitment is Promotion where workers are promoted from one sector to another with greater liability based upon the competence. Other methods include demotion and up gradation of current workers in accordance to their productivity (Sparrow, &Cooper, 1998). The purposes of selection function are to get the right person to the right job; unless unproductive staff will be filled in the organization. The selected staff essentials to be talented of doing the nominated job. This is the most significant factor in a correct recruitment and selection procedure (Gamage,2014).

    ReplyDelete